Stephen Musings

Not on my merit but by His Grace,

BYJU’S UNDER INDIAN CRICKET SPONSORS’ CURSE

Part 1 narrated the major events that transpired during the meteoric rise and fall of the Byju’s. To read click here

When individuals stumble, particularly after a period of societal or business success, they often face public scrutiny and are labeled as frauds, scammers, or exploiters. This phenomenon is exemplified in the case of Bayju Raveendran. Reactions on Byju’s journey in part 1 of this blog, underscore this tendency. Interestingly, I came across an Indian superstition or belief that adds another dimension to this narrative. Therefore, this supplementary section explores Byju’s saga through the lens of superstition.

Curses and superstitions are deeply rooted in Indian cultural storytelling, ranging from the fear of inauspicious days or times to common cautions about superstitions like a cat crossing your path. However, there’s a compelling story surrounding the fate of sponsors of the Indian cricket team.

The mysterious curse looming over the promoters of the Indian cricket team

Let’s explore the fate of various sponsors of the Indian cricket team:

WILLS: When the Indian government banned tobacco advertisements, Wills had to end its association with BCCI. Although the sponsoring company, ITC, continues to thrive, the brand ‘Wills’ has faded from public view.

SAHARA: Subrata Roy built a vast business empire, Sahara, spanning retail, real estate, and financial services. However, Roy faced controversies and legal battles, leading to the downfall of Sahara in 2013 and ending its partnership with BCCI. STAR: Disney’s acquisition of Star India in the same year it bought out Fox Star altered the situation. Consequently, Star India lost the right to broadcast the Indian Premier League (IPL) independently, which impacted its finances and its sponsorship of the Indian cricket team.

OPPO: Amid escalating tensions between India and China, the Indian government imposed restrictions on Chinese companies like Oppo. Oppo’s prominence waned, leading it to withdraw from sports sponsorships.

BYJU’S: Byju’s held the largest sponsorship contract, paying Rs 5 Cr per match to BCCI. However, burdened by financial woes, Byju’s defaulted on payments totaling Rs 156 Cr, leading to the premature termination of its contract in early 2023. On 15 July 2024, NCLT admitted an insolvency petition by BCCI. That means insolvency proceedings on Byju’s will start immediately.

Dream11: The online gaming app took over sponsorship in June 2023. However, the Indian government’s imposition of a hefty 28% Goods and Services Tax (GST) on fantasy sports platforms poses a financial challenge. This levy could potentially affect Dream11’s ability to fulfill its sponsorship commitment to the Indian cricket team in the long term.

Can we attribute the downfall of Byju’s to the superstition theory?

Entertaining the notion of this curse is akin to agreeing with a batsman who blames the captain for sending him in when the bowler is on a hat-trick.

To read Part 1, Chronicle of Rise and Fall of Byju’s click here

2 responses to “BYJU’S UNDER INDIAN CRICKET SPONSORS’ CURSE”

  1. In Act 1 Scene 5 of Shakespeare’s play, Hamlet, Hamlet says to his friend:

    “There are more things in Heaven and Earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy.” 

    Myths, long standing beliefs, superstitions and such others have existed all through the history of human beings. I have always held an open mind about all these things, and have never rejected them outright, because history is full of narratives about firm beliefs which have later been proved to be mere fallacies, and long held “fallacies” which have subsequently been proved to be absolutely factual.

    That said, the superstition regarding the relationship between BCCI and their sponsors may be left open for belief or dismissal, according to personal convenience. The fact remains that all the sponsors mentioned in the blog went downhill from where they stood at the time they took up the sponsorship. In each case, it is seen that there were logical reasons for what happened. Like KINGFISHER, KODAK or NOKIA, there have been so many other national and international brands which have gone through a similar situation.

    Personally, I have always been skeptical about the meteoric growth of any company, and here again history has given us so many examples of such growth and downfall.

    The investment philosophies of Warren Buffet and Charlie Munger need to be studied for very valuable lessons in investment planning, business and even in personal life.

    There is a saying “If something looks too good to be true, it probably is!” This is definitely a valuable principle which needs to be accepted across all sections of society.

    Like

    1. Dill
      You have taken this to a different level.
      Thanks Dill

      Like

Leave a comment